Seanad asked for general statement on farm rates
Senator Victor Boyhan used a Seanad Commencement matter on 19 November 2026 to ask Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine Martin Heydon to make a general statement on the implications for farming if commercial rates are applied to agricultural buildings.
Boyhan told the House he sought only a wider Government response to a recent court ruling, not debate about any particular premises. He said: "My matter requested that the Minister for agriculture make a general statement; I do not want to get into the specifics, nor will the Minister."
He said it would not be right or appropriate to discuss any site or enterprise, but he wanted a statement on the recent ruling of the court that could potentially expose agricultural buildings to commercial rates. He said farmers, growers and producers whose facilities are currently outside the commercial rates scheme were seeking assurances that the status quo would remain and that any unintended consequences would be addressed.
Houses of the Oireachtas
- Seanad debate on Commercial Rates, 19 November 2026
The recent High Court decision the Senator referenced has resulted in certain farm buildings being found to be rateable.
Why temperature-controlled storage is central
Boyhan said the court judgment may affect temperature-controlled potato, onion and vegetable stores and facilities used by dairy farmers as well as agricultural, horticultural and related food producers. The case involved a potato company and Tailte Éireann, whose property evaluations underpin rates collected by local authorities.
Heydon told the Seanad: "The recent High Court decision the Senator referenced has resulted in certain farm buildings being found to be rateable." He said the key issue was the finding that storing horticultural produce in a temperature-controlled environment amounted to "processing", which is an exception to exemption from commercial rates under the Valuation Act 2001.
The Act provides an exemption for farm buildings, defined to include buildings occupied together with agricultural land, buildings used solely for livestock production and horticultural farm buildings as provided for in the Act. Heydon said buildings used for processing have previously and continue to be rateable.
To illustrate the line, Heydon said: "With potatoes, for example, a farmer should be able to take a potato into a shed and store it until it is sold to market and that would not be rateable." By contrast, peeling, chipping and bagging potatoes for dispatch was processing and rateable. He said consumers demand year-round supply of staples such as potatoes and onions, and storage that prevents spoilage has become integral to horticulture before produce is processed and placed on the market.
Houses of the Oireachtas
- Seanad debate on Commercial Rates, 19 November 2026
The recent High Court decision the Senator referenced has resulted in certain farm buildings being found to be rateable.
Irish Examiner
- High Court ruling raises concerns for farm rates and essential farm sheds
Following a High Court ruling that makes potato and onion storage buildings liable for commercial rates, concerns have been raised about the decision's far-reaching consequences.
Farm groups warn of threat to sheds
Macra na Feirme warned the decision could have major implications for farmers and horticultural producers across Ireland, saying facilities that protect produce and maintain quality are vital to a reliable food supply. The Irish Examiner reported that the ruling in the case involving Castlecor Potato Company and Tailte Éireann raised concerns that rates could be applied to other essential agricultural and horticultural storage buildings.
Macra president Josephine O’Neill said: "Whether a farm building is used to house a bulk tank to cool milk, store potatoes or onions, or keep hay and straw, these facilities are essential to the day-to-day operation of a farm and have traditionally been exempt from rates under the Valuation Act."
She added: "It is madness to me that the storage of potatoes and onions could be described as an act of processing." Macra said farmers should not face additional costs for necessary infrastructure and called for urgent action to address the implications and for the decision to be overturned on appeal, should the case proceed to the Supreme Court.
In the Seanad, Boyhan said the sector was under enormous pressure and profitability was critical to keeping people in business, particularly in food and horticulture tied to food security. He said: "It is great to hear there will be a cross-government examination of it and greater clarity on the implications of the court judgment but farmers, growers and food producers who are currently outside the commercial rates system are seeking assurances."
Houses of the Oireachtas
- Seanad debate on Commercial Rates, 19 November 2026
The recent High Court decision the Senator referenced has resulted in certain farm buildings being found to be rateable.
Irish Examiner
- High Court ruling raises concerns for farm rates and essential farm sheds
Following a High Court ruling that makes potato and onion storage buildings liable for commercial rates, concerns have been raised about the decision's far-reaching consequences.
What ministers will examine next
Céim a bhfuil súil léi: D’fhéadfadh an méid seo athrú.
Heydon said commercial rates fall under the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage under the 2017 Valuation Office and Valuation Tribunal order, but he was addressing the Seanad because rates directly affect agriculture. He said he and the Minister of State with responsibility for horticulture had written to the housing Minister and requested engagement on the potential implications.
He said the Government's policy rationale was that food production operates on tight margins and storage of agricultural produce in large units would face significant liability if rateable, so storage had been exempted. That position changes if processing is involved, he said.
Heydon said the implications of the recent adjudication, including any appeal outcome, need to be considered carefully. He told Boyhan: "I will work really closely with the Minister, Deputy Browne, on this."
Boyhan thanked the Minister for his comprehensive response and asked that the matter be kept under review, with initial focus on those currently outside rates. Heydon said the Government would watch how the changed interpretation plays out and whether there is any appeal.
Houses of the Oireachtas
- Seanad debate on Commercial Rates, 19 November 2026
The recent High Court decision the Senator referenced has resulted in certain farm buildings being found to be rateable.
Conas a rinneadh an scéal seo: dréachtaíonn DáilDex nuacht go huathoibríoch ó thaifid oifigiúla agus ó thuairisciú náisiúnta, agus seiceálann sé gach foinse agus sliocht roimh fhoilsiú. Léigh ár modheolaíocht
Foinsí
2 foinse
Oifigiúil / Príomhúil
- Houses of the Oireachtas — Seanad debate on Commercial Rates, 19 November 2026
“The recent High Court decision the Senator referenced has resulted in certain farm buildings being found to be rateable.”
Tuairisciú
- Irish Examiner — High Court ruling raises concerns for farm rates and essential farm sheds
“Following a High Court ruling that makes potato and onion storage buildings liable for commercial rates, concerns have been raised about the decision's far-reaching consequences.”