Higgins criticises plan to drop UN mandate
Former president Michael D Higgins has said Ireland is "sliding" into military alliances under the Government's plan to scrap the triple lock. He made the remarks in an Irish Examiner interview published on Saturday 24 October 2026, after a heated Dáil debate in which opposition members called for a referendum on the proposed changes.
The former president questioned the Government's account of the reform. "I would say now because I've had so much time to think about it, I think that it's less than honest not to give the full story when you're talking about going into preparatory alliances, and I really do feel that because I dealt with senior army people in my 15 years as president," he said.
"In fact, actually, what you're having, and critics are right in saying it, is that people are sliding into things rather than choosing to decide to go into things." The interview also ranged across Gaza, climate change and artificial intelligence, which he warned is now a threat to democracy.
Irish Examiner
- Michael D Higgins warns Ireland is ‘sliding’ into military alliances over triple lock
Mr Higgins's comments on the triple lock come after a heated debate in the Dáil this week during which members of the opposition called for a referendum on the proposed changes.
What the triple-lock change would mean
Ireland decides to participate on missions on a case-by-case basis through a mechanism called the ‘Triple Lock’. For Ireland to deploy more than 12 troops overseas, three conditions must be met: a UN mandate for the mission, approval by the Irish Government, and approval by Dáil Éireann.
The Irish Government has proposed reforms to the Triple Lock, removing the requirement for a UN mandate and increasing the threshold for overseas troop deployments from 12 to 50. The Government argues that the UN Security Council veto held by permanent members such as Russia and China can unduly restrict Ireland’s ability to take part in peacekeeping operations.
These proposals have sparked significant political debate and have not yet been implemented. In practical terms, deployments involving more than 12 Irish peacekeepers currently require UN Security Council approval, so the Council's failings directly affect the legal basis for Irish participation.
European Commission - Ireland Representation
- Ireland and EU defence & security
The Irish Government has proposed reforms to the Triple Lock, removing the requirement for a UN mandate and increasing the threshold for overseas troop deployments from 12 to 50.
Irish Examiner
- Michael D Higgins warns Ireland is ‘sliding’ into military alliances over triple lock
Mr Higgins's comments on the triple lock come after a heated debate in the Dáil this week during which members of the opposition called for a referendum on the proposed changes.
What the minister said in the Dáil debate
Speaking during the Dáil debate this week, foreign affairs minister Helen McEntee argued that currently the five members of the UN Security Council — France, the UK, China, the US and Russia — decide and have a role in where we take part and how we contribute to certain international missions. The Government contends that removing the triple lock will allow for continued deployment of Irish peacekeepers.
That argument frames the reform as a way to protect Ireland's peacekeeping role from deadlock in New York, rather than as a change to neutrality. Ireland’s military neutrality is protected by legally binding guarantees in a Protocol attached to the Lisbon Treaty, assurances given after voters initially rejected the Treaty in a 2008 referendum and approved it in a second referendum in 2009.
RTÉ's This Week listed a 19-minute interview with Minister McEntee about the debate for Sunday 25 October. The listing says the programme examined why the Government curtailed debate to four hours, amid opposition claims that discussion of a key national issue was being stifled.
Irish Examiner
- Michael D Higgins warns Ireland is ‘sliding’ into military alliances over triple lock
Mr Higgins's comments on the triple lock come after a heated debate in the Dáil this week during which members of the opposition called for a referendum on the proposed changes.
European Commission - Ireland Representation
- Ireland and EU defence & security
The Irish Government has proposed reforms to the Triple Lock, removing the requirement for a UN mandate and increasing the threshold for overseas troop deployments from 12 to 50.
RTÉ
- Minister Helen McEntee on Triple Lock debate
Paul speaks to Minister Helen McEntee about the Triple Lock Dáil debate why the Government curtailed it to just four hours, leading to Opposition claims that a vital debate on a key national issue was being stiffled.
Why Higgins says UN reform should come first
Mr Higgins said there has been a “totally insufficient attempt” at reforming the UN and addressing “the abusive position in the Security Council”. He suggested little effort had been made to address the failings of the Council that the Government cites as justification for change.
He questioned what kind of deployments could follow reform: "Are we going to wait for the European Union to tell us where to go to become active for peace?" He added: "The evidence is that the European Union is not in favour of that kind of peace."
He also drew a comparison between NATO and EU leadership, saying: "I think that many times people looking at interviews wonder what's the difference between the secretary general of Nato and the President of the European Commission, it's kind of a competition in trying to sound fierce." He said a person speaking about the promise and prospects of peace would now find it very hard to get a space, after a short period in which discourse became entirely militarised.
Irish Examiner
- Michael D Higgins warns Ireland is ‘sliding’ into military alliances over triple lock
Mr Higgins's comments on the triple lock come after a heated debate in the Dáil this week during which members of the opposition called for a referendum on the proposed changes.
Neutrality and peacekeeping background
Military neutrality is described as a defining feature of Ireland's foreign policy, with the Constitution preventing Ireland from joining a European army or mutual defence pact. Ireland balances that position with its responsibility as an EU member state to be a trusted security partner.
Ireland’s proud record of participation in UN and EU peacekeeping missions is described as consistent with both its neutrality and its international obligations. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, alongside cyberattacks, disinformation and energy supply disruptions, is cited as part of the new security context facing Europe.
Defence remains the responsibility of individual EU member states, while Ireland participates on a strict opt-in basis in projects such as maritime surveillance and cyber protection. By early 2025, Ireland had committed about €350 million in European Peace Facility funding, largely for support to Ukraine.
European Commission - Ireland Representation
- Ireland and EU defence & security
The Irish Government has proposed reforms to the Triple Lock, removing the requirement for a UN mandate and increasing the threshold for overseas troop deployments from 12 to 50.
What happens next for peacekeepers
Céim a bhfuil súil léi: D’fhéadfadh an méid seo athrú.
The proposals to remove the UN-mandate requirement and raise the troop threshold to 50 have not yet been implemented. Any change would therefore still require a political decision and legislation before the rules for authorising overseas deployments alter.
For Defence Forces families and communities with a peacekeeping tradition, the practical question is who authorises the next deployment above the threshold. Under the current lock, missions of more than 12 troops need a UN mandate as well as Government and Dáil approval.
European Commission - Ireland Representation
- Ireland and EU defence & security
The Irish Government has proposed reforms to the Triple Lock, removing the requirement for a UN mandate and increasing the threshold for overseas troop deployments from 12 to 50.
Conas a rinneadh an scéal seo: dréachtaíonn DáilDex nuacht go huathoibríoch ó thaifid oifigiúla agus ó thuairisciú náisiúnta, agus seiceálann sé gach foinse agus sliocht roimh fhoilsiú. Léigh ár modheolaíocht
Foinsí
3 foinse
Oifigiúil / Príomhúil
- European Commission - Ireland Representation — Ireland and EU defence & security
“The Irish Government has proposed reforms to the Triple Lock, removing the requirement for a UN mandate and increasing the threshold for overseas troop deployments from 12 to 50.”
Tuairisciú
- Irish Examiner — Michael D Higgins warns Ireland is ‘sliding’ into military alliances over triple lock
“Mr Higgins's comments on the triple lock come after a heated debate in the Dáil this week during which members of the opposition called for a referendum on the proposed changes.”
- RTÉ — Minister Helen McEntee on Triple Lock debate
“Paul speaks to Minister Helen McEntee about the Triple Lock Dáil debate why the Government curtailed it to just four hours, leading to Opposition claims that a vital debate on a key national issue was being stiffled.”