Social Democrats answer Harris unity invitation
The Social Democrats have proposed four actions to progress work towards a united Ireland, including the establishment of an Oireachtas committee with a specific brief to further that goal.
Acting leader Cian O’Callaghan set out the plan in a letter responding to Tánaiste Simon Harris, who had written to all political parties inviting ideas on how unity can be achieved. O’Callaghan is the first party leader from the South to respond in writing to the letter sent out by Harris to all parties in the State and in the North.
It came after the Fine Gael leader unveiled his party’s blueprint for a united Ireland at its ardfheis in Cork earlier this month. In his reply, O’Callaghan told the Government parties: “As parties of Government you have the power to do much more than publish disparate discussion documents or proposals. You can begin the essential work that is required to make a new Ireland a reality.”
The Irish Times
- Social Democrats propose new Oireachtas committee to progress Irish unity
The Social Democrats have proposed four actions to progress work towards a united Ireland, including the establishment of an Oireachtas committee with a specific brief to further that goal.
What the four proposals would do
The party sets out proposals for an all-island social and economic commission, and a new Oireachtas committee to agree a framework for a united Ireland within the terms of the Good Friday Agreement.
O’Callaghan writes that members of the Northern Ireland Assembly should be invited to participate in the proposed Oireachtas committee alongside TDs and Senators.
It also says a policy paper (or Green Paper) should be produced and then opened to the public in both Northern Ireland and the Repubic for consultation. Its fourth proposal is for an all-island civil discussion.
The consultation phase of the Green Paper should be open to accepting public views and expert opinion on the constitutional change required, O’Callaghan states. That should include consultation with the UK government and with all the political parties in Northern Ireland.
On the final proposal, an all-island civic discussion, O’Callaghan argues that the separate proposals from Government parties do not include a meaningful role for members of the public. “The process should be as inclusive and democratic as possible, bringing to the table a diverse range of perspectives and relating the conversation to the concerns of ordinary people.”
The Irish Times
- Social Democrats propose new Oireachtas committee to progress Irish unity
The Social Democrats have proposed four actions to progress work towards a united Ireland, including the establishment of an Oireachtas committee with a specific brief to further that goal.
Why the Government was pressed to act
The position of the Social Democrats since its inception, O’Callaghan writes, is that it believes in unity through consent. He said preparation must involve detailed policy work, stating there has to be a “robust social and economic analysis of the implications of constitutional change and it must “necessarily go beyond fiscal costs”.
He cites healthcare, housing, education, childcare, social protection, infrastructure, energy and regional development. “Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil have now announced separate proposals but have not adopted an agreed Government position on this critical issue.
The context for the proposed committee includes an existing Oireachtas body, the Joint Committee on the Implementation of the Good Friday Agreement. Fine Gael’s own blueprint had suggested appointing a junior minister in the Irish government for “north south relations”.
The party also published a document by an economist who works as an adviser to Harris, where it was suggested that the first-year cost of reunification ranges from about €3bn (£2.5bn) to €25bn (£20.8bn) to the Irish exchequer.
The Irish Times
- Social Democrats propose new Oireachtas committee to progress Irish unity
The Social Democrats have proposed four actions to progress work towards a united Ireland, including the establishment of an Oireachtas committee with a specific brief to further that goal.
Houses of the Oireachtas
- Oireachtas committee schedule
Joint Committee on the Implementation of the Good Friday Agreement
BBC News
- Harris asks politicians for feedback on Irish unity 'blueprint'
Among their proposals, Fine Gael has suggested appointing a junior minister in the Irish government for "north south relations".
Mixed reaction across the island
There has been mixed reaction to Harris’s letter. SDLP leader Claire Hanna welcomed it, and Alliance leader Naomi Long said her party would engage “without prejudice”. But Ulster Unionist Party leader Jon Burrows responded by saying his party had no interest.
DUP leader Gavin Robinson was also dismissive, describing it as a crass effort by Fine Gael to outflank other parties in the South on the issue.
Sinn Féin welcomed the initiative. Leader Mary Lou McDonald emphasised her party’s position that the questions of unity and preparing for a referendum or a Border poll were now urgent.
The Irish Times
- Social Democrats propose new Oireachtas committee to progress Irish unity
The Social Democrats have proposed four actions to progress work towards a united Ireland, including the establishment of an Oireachtas committee with a specific brief to further that goal.
What happens next on unity preparation
Céim a bhfuil súil léi: D’fhéadfadh an méid seo athrú.
Harris, who is the tánaiste (Irish deputy prime minister), said he and the Taoiseach (Irish PM) Micheál Martin are “aligned” on the issue. He said there could be joint Irish government proposals on Irish unity preparation “by the end of the year”.
He added that he had already had discussions with the Taoiseach Micheál Martin. The two parties are both in a coalition government, supported by a number of Independent TDs (members of the Irish parliament) in Dublin.
The debate also covers when a Border poll could be called. Under the Good Friday Agreement, Bryant as the NI Secretary of State, decides whether to call a border poll or not. Northern Ireland Secretary Sir Chris Bryant said he does not “detect a mood” for it now, while Harris said Dublin and London having a conversation about criteria would be useful and “is also just good governance”.
BBC News
- Harris says talk with UK on border poll criteria would be useful
He said there could be joint Irish government proposals on Irish unity preparation "by the end of the year".
Conas a rinneadh an scéal seo: dréachtaíonn DáilDex nuacht go huathoibríoch ó thaifid oifigiúla agus ó thuairisciú náisiúnta, agus seiceálann sé gach foinse agus sliocht roimh fhoilsiú. Léigh ár modheolaíocht
Foinsí
4 foinse
Oifigiúil / Príomhúil
- Houses of the Oireachtas — Oireachtas committee schedule
“Joint Committee on the Implementation of the Good Friday Agreement”
Tuairisciú
- The Irish Times — Social Democrats propose new Oireachtas committee to progress Irish unity
“The Social Democrats have proposed four actions to progress work towards a united Ireland, including the establishment of an Oireachtas committee with a specific brief to further that goal.”
- BBC News — Harris asks politicians for feedback on Irish unity 'blueprint'
“Among their proposals, Fine Gael has suggested appointing a junior minister in the Irish government for "north south relations".”
- BBC News — Harris says talk with UK on border poll criteria would be useful
“He said there could be joint Irish government proposals on Irish unity preparation "by the end of the year".”