Motion defeated in the Dáil
The Dáil rejected a motion calling for a windfall tax on energy companies on 30 September 2026. A Government amendment rejecting the motion passed by 76 votes to 66, and the question on agreeing the motion as amended also carried by 76 votes to 66, according to the parliamentary result.
The motion was tabled by Social Democrats energy spokesperson Jennifer Whitmore. RTÉ reported that the proposal sought to tax energy companies’ profits during a cost-of-living crisis; its defeat means the original motion will not become law.
Houses of the Oireachtas
RTÉ
- Energy windfall tax motion rejected by Dáil
The Social Democrats motion calling for a windfall tax on energy firms was defeated in a Dáil vote Fiachra Ó Cionnaith
Why the proposal was raised
The debate formed part of a wider argument about energy bills and the cost of living. RTÉ reported that the Social Democrats, Labour, Sinn Féin, the Green Party and People Before Profit-Solidarity had raised the possibility of a windfall tax in recent weeks and months, with parties arguing for energy firms to lower bills or pay additional taxes.
In a Dáil Leaders’ Questions debate the previous Thursday, Tánaiste Simon Harris said he was not necessarily opposed to a windfall tax in future. RTÉ reported that he said any future move would need careful examination and might ultimately be discussed at EU rather than Irish level because of its potential implications; some parties argued that tax matters were a national rather than EU responsibility.
RTÉ
- Energy windfall tax motion rejected by Dáil
The Social Democrats motion calling for a windfall tax on energy firms was defeated in a Dáil vote Fiachra Ó Cionnaith
Budget debate on household costs
Energy costs were also a focus of a Dáil debate on 24 September, ahead of the budget scheduled for 6 October. The Irish Times reported that Sinn Féin finance spokesperson Pearse Doherty warned of electricity and gas price rises that would affect a million households, saying that families using both would face an increase of more than €300 a year.
Harris said the Government was working on a temporary package to provide assistance and certainty on energy. He said it would provide “certainty for the winter period on excise” and referred to reductions in carbon tax on different products, while warning that there was “a limitation to how much you can do” without challenging the European system.
Doherty renewed Sinn Féin’s call for a targeted €400 energy credit. The Irish Times also reported that Whitmore called for a windfall tax on energy companies and a €400 targeted credit for low- and middle-income earners.
The Irish Times
- Help is on the way in budget with energy costs, Simon Harris says
He said these increases would affect a million households and for families using gas and electricity, “the increase will be more than €300 a year”. READ MORE
What the vote means
The parliamentary question carried was: “That the motion, as amended, be agreed to”. The official result records that question as carried by 76 votes to 66; RTÉ reported that the Government amendment rejected the original motion and that the proposed windfall tax would not become law.
The budget debate was due to continue into the following week, with the budget scheduled for 6 October, according to The Irish Times. The reporting describes the windfall-tax proposal as one element of the broader debate over how to respond to rising household energy costs.
Houses of the Oireachtas
RTÉ
- Energy windfall tax motion rejected by Dáil
The Social Democrats motion calling for a windfall tax on energy firms was defeated in a Dáil vote Fiachra Ó Cionnaith
The Irish Times
- Help is on the way in budget with energy costs, Simon Harris says
He said these increases would affect a million households and for families using gas and electricity, “the increase will be more than €300 a year”. READ MORE
Conas a rinneadh an scéal seo: dréachtaíonn DáilDex nuacht go huathoibríoch ó thaifid oifigiúla agus ó thuairisciú náisiúnta, agus seiceálann sé gach foinse agus sliocht roimh fhoilsiú. Léigh ár modheolaíocht
Foinsí
3 foinse
Oifigiúil / Príomhúil
Tuairisciú
- RTÉ — Energy windfall tax motion rejected by Dáil
“The Social Democrats motion calling for a windfall tax on energy firms was defeated in a Dáil vote Fiachra Ó Cionnaith”
- The Irish Times — Help is on the way in budget with energy costs, Simon Harris says
“He said these increases would affect a million households and for families using gas and electricity, “the increase will be more than €300 a year”. READ MORE”