What the High Court decided
The High Court has ruled that a teenager with active epilepsy is to be treated with anti-seizure medication against her mother's wishes. In a judgment published on Thursday, Judge Conor Dignam granted an application by Tusla, the child and family agency, supported by the girl's father and guardian, for orders for administration of the prescribed medication.
The orders require the mother to store the medication at home and make it accessible to a public-health nurse. They also require her to permit the nurse to enter the home, along with two agency staff already dealing with family welfare, and to permit administration of the medication there.
The Courts Service lists the case as Child and Family Agency -v- RA and KJ (In the matter of GG), decided by Dignam J., delivered on 4 November 2026 and published on 12 November 2026 as [2026] IEHC 730. Final orders in the case will be made later this month.
The Irish Times
- Judge orders potentially life-saving medication for girl against mother’s wishes
A teenager with active epilepsy is to be treated with potentially life-saving anti-seizure medication against her mother’s wishes, the High Court has ruled.
Courts Service
- Judgments & Determinations search results
Child and Family Agency -v- RA and KJ (In the matter of GG) Judgment Court: High Court Judge: Dignam J. Delivered: 04 Nov 2026 Published: 12 Nov 2026 Neutral citation: [2026] IEHC 730
Extra.ie
- Judge orders teen must get medication for epilepsy
However Judge Dignam concluded: ‘Put simply, on the evidence, the balance is between a risk of temporary side effects and risk of serious injury or death.’ Final orders will be made later this month.
Why doctors said treatment was needed
The girl's treating doctors and an independent neurologist all agreed she has epilepsy and considered her life at risk if the prescribed medication is not administered. The court heard that during a seizure in a public venue earlier this year, the girl was unconscious for 12 minutes.
Judge Dignam heard that the 17-year-old experiences seizures and that the medical evidence is that she should take anti-seizure medication and rescue medication in the event of a prolonged seizure. He found the diagnosis of epilepsy "sound and correct", and ruled that administration of the medications is necessary and will be, or is likely to be, of benefit to the girl and in her best interests.
He described the choice as between "a risk of temporary side effects and risk of serious injury or death". In Extra.ie's account of the judgment, he concluded: "Put simply, on the evidence, the balance is between a risk of temporary side effects and risk of serious injury or death."
The judge also found that the doctors and independent neurologist agreed the seizures are epileptic and not caused by electromagnetic forces. He found the mother did not adduce any evidence to support her alternative diagnosis or preferred treatment.
The Irish Times
- Judge orders potentially life-saving medication for girl against mother’s wishes
A teenager with active epilepsy is to be treated with potentially life-saving anti-seizure medication against her mother’s wishes, the High Court has ruled.
Extra.ie
- Judge orders teen must get medication for epilepsy
However Judge Dignam concluded: ‘Put simply, on the evidence, the balance is between a risk of temporary side effects and risk of serious injury or death.’ Final orders will be made later this month.
What the mother told the court
The girl's mother does not accept she has epilepsy and has attributed her seizures to "electromagnetic" forces, including eclipses of the sun and moon, and a "blocked chakra", and refused to consent to treatment with anti-seizure and rescue medication. Extra.ie reported she also blamed a mobile phone mast and the solar eclipse for the seizures.
In a sworn statement, the mother said she has a strong religious belief and "lives her life by the holy scriptures and the guidance of Jesus Christ", Judge Conor Dignam noted. She is her daughter's full-time carer and has home schooled her for some years.
The woman previously stopped prescribed medication for her daughter due to what she described as "severe" side effects, including her daughter becoming aggressive and angry. She told the court her view is there are alternative methods and treatments available, and in her statement linked a previous prescription to what she described as a complete change of personality.
The girl's court-appointed guardian agreed there is a "warm and affectionate" bond between mother and daughter. However, they believed the mother is "very fixed" in her views and this impeded her daughter's ability to access services and to socialise.
The guardian said the mother's views included that she herself is "a magician", that the seizures were caused by a "blocked chakra" in her daughter's heart and that cling film could be wrapped around her daughter's chest to prevent "negative energy" reaching the chakra. Judge Dignam said all parties agreed there is a close and loving relationship between the girl and her mother and that, other than the medication issue, the mother provides proper care for her daughter, who has autism and a mild intellectual difficulty.
The Irish Times
- Judge orders potentially life-saving medication for girl against mother’s wishes
A teenager with active epilepsy is to be treated with potentially life-saving anti-seizure medication against her mother’s wishes, the High Court has ruled.
Extra.ie
- Judge orders teen must get medication for epilepsy
However Judge Dignam concluded: ‘Put simply, on the evidence, the balance is between a risk of temporary side effects and risk of serious injury or death.’ Final orders will be made later this month.
Why the judge found a failure of duty
Céim a bhfuil súil léi: D’fhéadfadh an méid seo athrú.
On the evidence, Judge Dignam was satisfied the mother's choice not to permit the administration of medication prejudicially affects the girl's health and welfare to such an extent that amounted to "a failure of parental duty" to her daughter. He was satisfied the court's orders were "proportionate" and they left intact the mother's other rights and responsibilities regarding her daughter's care.
Because the orders involved medical treatment and "an ongoing interference" with constitutional rights, the judge made provision for regular reviews of the situation. That review arrangement means the storage and administration of medication at home, and access by the nurse and Tusla staff, will return before the court.
The Irish Times
- Judge orders potentially life-saving medication for girl against mother’s wishes
A teenager with active epilepsy is to be treated with potentially life-saving anti-seizure medication against her mother’s wishes, the High Court has ruled.
Extra.ie
- Judge orders teen must get medication for epilepsy
However Judge Dignam concluded: ‘Put simply, on the evidence, the balance is between a risk of temporary side effects and risk of serious injury or death.’ Final orders will be made later this month.
Conas a rinneadh an scéal seo: dréachtaíonn DáilDex nuacht go huathoibríoch ó thaifid oifigiúla agus ó thuairisciú náisiúnta, agus seiceálann sé gach foinse agus sliocht roimh fhoilsiú. Léigh ár modheolaíocht
Foinsí
3 foinse
Oifigiúil / Príomhúil
- Courts Service — Judgments & Determinations search results
“Child and Family Agency -v- RA and KJ (In the matter of GG) Judgment Court: High Court Judge: Dignam J. Delivered: 04 Nov 2026 Published: 12 Nov 2026 Neutral citation: [2026] IEHC 730”
Tuairisciú
- The Irish Times — Judge orders potentially life-saving medication for girl against mother’s wishes
“A teenager with active epilepsy is to be treated with potentially life-saving anti-seizure medication against her mother’s wishes, the High Court has ruled.”
- Extra.ie — Judge orders teen must get medication for epilepsy
“However Judge Dignam concluded: ‘Put simply, on the evidence, the balance is between a risk of temporary side effects and risk of serious injury or death.’ Final orders will be made later this month.”