Green groups open climate challenge over data centres
The High Court in Dublin began hearing a legal challenge on 17 November 2026 to the energy rules for connecting new data centres to the electricity network. The case was brought by Friends of the Irish Environment, Friends of the Earth Ireland and ClientEarth against the Commission for Regulation of Utilities, which announced the new framework last December.
The hearing opened before Judge Micheál O'Connell on Tuesday, with counsel for the environmental groups opening their case. The groups are seeking various reliefs, including an order quashing the CRU's decision to adopt the connection framework policy.
The dispute matters for Ireland's electricity system because the CRU says demand has risen sharply in recent years, driven largely by data centres. The regulator says total electricity demand has grown substantially over the past decade, with data centre demand greatly contributing to that growth, linking the courtroom argument to security of supply, renewable targets and carbon emissions.
The Irish Times
- High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
The High Court has begun hearing a challenge to a new framework allowing data centres to rely on fossil fuels to supply their electricity needs.
Irish Examiner
- High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
Three environmental groups — Friends of the Irish Environment, Friends of the Earth Ireland, and ClientEarth — claim the framework breaches climate legislation because it will facilitate an increase the country’s greenhouse gas emissions and lock-in long-term fossil fuel dependence.
What the CRU framework allows
Under the framework, data centres will be connected to the national grid if they supply as much electricity to the network as they take out of it. They can do so by building power generation plants on site or nearby, or by contracting energy companies to build them. The principle is that new demand is matched by new supply added to the system.
For the first six years, that extra electricity can be generated with fossil fuels. After that, 80 per cent of the electricity will have to come from renewables such as wind or solar farms the data centres build or contract energy companies to build, although 20 per cent can still be produced from gas or oil.
The CRU published the policy as a decision paper on the Large Energy Users connection policy, reference CRU2025236, on 12 December 2025. The regulator said its purpose was to set out a pathway for new data centre applications which addresses risks around security of supply and system constraints and promotes renewable energy targets, while minimising where possible the impact on national carbon emissions.
The decision also includes a new direction to electricity System Operators under Section 34 of the 1999 Electricity Regulation Act. That direction supersedes an earlier direction, CRU/21/124, and applies to new connection applications for new or additional capacity covered by the decision.
The Irish Times
- High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
The High Court has begun hearing a challenge to a new framework allowing data centres to rely on fossil fuels to supply their electricity needs.
Commission for Regulation of Utilities
- Review of Large Energy Users connection policy
The CRU has today, 12 December 2025, published a decision paper on the Large Energy Users connection policy (CRU2025236).
Why electricity demand puts the rules under pressure
In recent years, there has been a step-change in electricity demand growth driven by Large Energy Users, largely driven by the increase in data centre developments. The CRU says Ireland's total electricity demand has grown by 30 per cent over the past 10 years, with data centre demand having greatly contributed to that increase.
There are about 90 data centres in Ireland, the majority of which are located in the greater Dublin region. Data centres are used to supply processing power for cloud-based services such as social media, placing concentrated new load on the grid in the region where most facilities are situated.
The environmental groups claim the framework breaches climate legislation because it will facilitate increased greenhouse gas emissions and lock in long-term fossil fuel dependence. That is the groups' contention, not a finding, and it is contested. The CRU, by contrast, said new data centres connecting under the policy will be required to provide new renewable and dispatchable electricity generation, with the associated investment helping to address renewable energy targets and security of supply in the context of the additional demand.
Commission for Regulation of Utilities
- Review of Large Energy Users connection policy
The CRU has today, 12 December 2025, published a decision paper on the Large Energy Users connection policy (CRU2025236).
Irish Examiner
- Environmental groups take case over CRU data centres decision
There are about 90 data centres in Ireland, the majority of which are located in the greater Dublin region.
From moratorium to new connection pathway
The framework ended a de facto moratorium on the connection of new data centres to the national electricity network from 2021, put in place due to strains on the electricity supply. Its replacement reopens a route for new projects, provided they meet the requirement to add matching generation.
The policy followed a review that began with a call for evidence paper in June 2023, followed by a consultation paper in January 2024 and a proposed decision paper in February 2025. The CRU published the call for evidence as CRU202357, the consultation as CRU2024001 and the proposed decision as CRU202504 before issuing the final decision.
Responses received to the proposed decision paper which were not marked confidential were made available through the CRU consultation portal. One submission, from the grassroots group Not Here Not Anywhere, welcomed a longer-term approach but argued that current strategies undercut decarbonisation.
That submission said data centre demand undercut decarbonisation and increased reliance on further fossil-fuel generation because of extensive electricity and water use. It urged requirements for new on-site renewables, battery storage to shift and manage peak loads, and limits on on-site fossil-fuel generation, arguing that grid development should focus on renewables, storage, demand-side management and interconnection.
The Irish Times
- High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
The High Court has begun hearing a challenge to a new framework allowing data centres to rely on fossil fuels to supply their electricity needs.
Commission for Regulation of Utilities (2)
- Review of Large Energy Users connection policy
The CRU has today, 12 December 2025, published a decision paper on the Large Energy Users connection policy (CRU2025236).
- Not Here Not Anywhere submission to Large Energy Users review
Unfortunately, data centres under current and proposed strategies undercut our potential to decarbonise society and increase reliance on further fossil fuel generation due to their extensive electricity and water usage.
What the groups told the court
The core of the groups' case, as opened on Tuesday, is that the CRU breached its obligations under the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Act 2015. Part of the case relies on the assertion that the regulator must perform its functions in a manner consistent with the State's climate action plan and the furtherance of the national climate objective.
The groups submit that the breaches arise from the CRU's alleged failure to consider whether adopting the framework would cause climate targets outlined in the State's climate action plan, including carbon budgets and emission ceilings, to be exceeded. They therefore ask how the regulator could act consistently with its 2015 Act duties without taking those budgets and ceilings into account.
James Devlin, counsel for the environmental groups, instructed by FP Logue, said that in their case, they were asking “rhetorically” how the CRU could perform its functions consistent with its obligations under the 2015 Act, in circumstances where it did not take carbon budgets and emission ceiling targets into account. He also submitted that there was an acknowledgment by the CRU in a proposed decision paper of the link between the policy and legally binding climate targets.
The argument relies on a recent Supreme Court judgment that clarified climate law obligations of planning authorities and public bodies. The relevance of that judgment to an energy regulator's connection policy is expected to be central to the court's analysis, and no findings had been made on the opening day.
Irish Examiner
- High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
Three environmental groups — Friends of the Irish Environment, Friends of the Earth Ireland, and ClientEarth — claim the framework breaches climate legislation because it will facilitate an increase the country’s greenhouse gas emissions and lock-in long-term fossil fuel dependence.
The Irish Times
- High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
The High Court has begun hearing a challenge to a new framework allowing data centres to rely on fossil fuels to supply their electricity needs.
What happens next in court
Expected next step: This may change.
Lawyers for the CRU will outline its defence on Wednesday. That will give the court the regulator's account of how the framework was developed and why it considers the phased move from fossil-fuel generation to a predominantly renewables-based requirement to be lawful.
The hearing is a judicial review of the decision to adopt the policy, not a planning decision on any individual data centre. The groups are seeking orders including quashing the decision to adopt the connection framework policy.
The case reached court after judicial review papers were lodged in March 2026 by Friends of the Irish Environment, Friends of the Earth Ireland and ClientEarth Limited against the CRU's final decision last December on how large energy users are powered. All three groups are represented by solicitors FP Logue.
For readers, the practical question is the terms on which large new electricity users can connect in the coming years, and how quickly that demand must be matched by new wind, solar and other capacity. Further hearings and, in due course, a judgment will determine whether the framework stands.
The Irish Times
- High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
The High Court has begun hearing a challenge to a new framework allowing data centres to rely on fossil fuels to supply their electricity needs.
Irish Examiner
- Environmental groups take case over CRU data centres decision
There are about 90 data centres in Ireland, the majority of which are located in the greater Dublin region.
How this story was made: DáilDex drafts news automatically from official records and national reporting, then checks every cited source and quote before publishing. Read our methodology
Sources
5 sources
Official / Primary
- Commission for Regulation of Utilities — Review of Large Energy Users connection policy
“The CRU has today, 12 December 2025, published a decision paper on the Large Energy Users connection policy (CRU2025236).”
- Commission for Regulation of Utilities — Not Here Not Anywhere submission to Large Energy Users review
“Unfortunately, data centres under current and proposed strategies undercut our potential to decarbonise society and increase reliance on further fossil fuel generation due to their extensive electricity and water usage.”
Reporting
- The Irish Times — High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
“The High Court has begun hearing a challenge to a new framework allowing data centres to rely on fossil fuels to supply their electricity needs.”
- Irish Examiner — High Court begins hearing challenge to data centre energy policy
“Three environmental groups — Friends of the Irish Environment, Friends of the Earth Ireland, and ClientEarth — claim the framework breaches climate legislation because it will facilitate an increase the country’s greenhouse gas emissions and lock-in long-term fossil fuel dependence.”
- Irish Examiner — Environmental groups take case over CRU data centres decision
“There are about 90 data centres in Ireland, the majority of which are located in the greater Dublin region.”