Dáil vote · 8 November 2023
DáilDex record: 73eabdd7
Home Care Workers and Home Support Scheme: Motion (Resumed) [Private Members]
Question put: "That the motion, as amended, be agreed to".
See how the TDs for your area voted, and get told next time.
How did your TDs vote?
Only the first three characters of your Eircode are used, and only in your browser.
What this vote means
Policy motion
A policy motion expresses the House's position or calls for action. It does not itself change the law or legally require the Government to carry out the policy requested.
Tá means yes and Níl means no to the exact question put. The vote alone does not establish a TD's full position or reasons.
DáilDex interpretation of the official wording.
The full text TDs voted on
This vote decided the motion as amended. Earlier in this debate amendment No. 1 replaced the original wording, so Tá supported the amendment's text below, not the original motion.
A motion can bundle several proposals together. Tá or Níl applies to the whole question put, so a TD may agree with one part and still vote against it because of another. Read the full wording, and the debate where TDs gave their reasons, before treating this vote as a position on any single point.
The motion as moved
That Dáil Éireann:
acknowledges that:
— there is still no statutory right to home help or legislative underpinning for the home support scheme despite long standing commitments to act;
— the delayed referendum to replace Article 41.2 of Bunreacht na hÉireann , if passed, will finally insert language that recognises and values care within the home and the wider community; and
— the Commission on Care for Older Persons is due to finally get underway in January 2024, and while Ireland has a growing population, it also has an ageing demographic profile requiring increased resourcing of elder care;
recognises that:
— the State has a central role in providing care for people in the community and in their home, but there is growing healthcare privatisation through the outsourcing of more and more care, diagnostics, treatments, employment and services instead of investing in the permanent capacity of our public health service;
— over 60 per cent of State-funded home care is provided by private and voluntary providers, but there is no requirement for these contractors to engage in collective bargaining, despite a long-standing recruitment crisis in the sector; and
— home carers directly employed by the Health Service Executive (HSE) as Health Care Support Assistants (HCSAs) have better pay, and stronger terms and conditions compared to those working for private providers, creating a two-tier workforce and pay disparity for people doing the same job;
notes that:
— the health budget for 2023 originally funded over 23.9 million hours of home support in the HSE National Service Plan 2023, with a total budget of €723 million, but this was cut to 22 million hours in July in order to fund an increased rate of €31 per hour for providers, a so-called "living wage" floor of €13.10 per hour for workers and payment for travel time;
— Budget 2024 provides again for only 22 million home support hours, and allocated just an extra €2.8 million in funding for inflationary pressures, a 0.4 per cent increase;
— as of the end of June 2023, 10.55 million home support hours were delivered nationally to 53,579 people with a further 6,020 people assessed and waiting for a carer to be assigned, but no data is collected on how long people must wait;
— before the new tender 40,000 people over the previous year received care through private providers charged to the HSE at a rate of €26.50 per hour, while workers still had no predictable income;
— under the new HSE Home Support Authorisation Scheme 2023, the day rate for providers is now €31 per hour, but payments to workers are not indexed to increases in the Living Wage, which is now at €14.80 per hour;
— in the public service a HCSA can start on more than €16 per hour rising to over €20 on their salary scale, while privately employed home carers are paid €13.10 per hour, with providers funded at a rate more than twice that;
— the HSE, in October, abandoned a cost saving plan that would have cut 15 minutes from an hour of private home help, reducing it to just 45 minutes; and
— it is a year since the publication of the Report of the Strategic Workforce Advisory Group on Home Carers and Nursing Home Health Care Assistants and while some recommendations have been partially acted on, there is no fully resourced implementation plan;
further notes that:
— the failure to fully resource the home support service and waiting lists for homecare packages leads to discharge delays in acute hospitals, and at the end of June there were nearly 500 delayed transfer of care patients;
— there is a postcode lottery when it comes to home care waiting lists, and evidence that those in rural areas wait longer due to a lack of mileage and travel costs for carers;
— social welfare rules create disincentives for part time work by home carers, reducing the hours they can work;
— the lack of progress on employment terms and conditions, including travel expenses, a competency framework, recognition of training, and a pension scheme, are further barriers to recruitment; and
— there has been a shocking inconsistency in the payment of the Covid-19 Pandemic Special Recognition Payment to home carers and other healthcare workers; and
calls for:
— the adequate funding of our health service, the immediate reversal of the recruitment embargo on health workers, and a commitment not to block the hiring of public service HCSAs;
— restoration of the 1.9 million hours of home help support cut in July 2023, and no cuts to the duration of home support hours;
— a guarantee that home carers are paid, at a minimum, the new Living Wage rate of €14.80, and payment to be provided for mileage expenses and travel time between care locations, along with guaranteed hours and continuity of income for HCSAs;
— a commitment in outsourced State contracts that private home care providers engage in collective bargaining with recognised trade unions, and the introduction of a Joint Labour Committee for workers in the private care sector to set employment standards;
— a published and resourced implementation plan for the recommendations of the Strategic Workforce Advisory Group report, to deliver on the recruitment needed to clear the current waiting list for home care and support before Christmas, and sufficient resources to be put in place to address the winter health crisis;
— annual targets to increase the proportion of home support hours provided directly by the HSE, in order to achieve a publicly provided service;
— the collection of data by the HSE on how long people are waiting for home care and the adequacy of the hours granted;
— the payment of the Covid-19 Pandemic Special Recognition Payment to those home and family carers, and all those other health workers in Health Information and Quality Authority registered settings excluded to date;
— an end to the payment disparity between home support for older people, and those with disabilities; and
— a commitment to the referendum to recognise care work in 2024.
Amendment No. 1Decided in this vote
To delete all words after "Dáil Eireann" and substitute the following:
"recognises and notes:
— the invaluable work carried out by Home Care Support Assistants;
— that the Home Support Service is a core service for older people and is highly valued by service users;
— improving access to home support is a priority for the Government, with €723 million allocated in Budget 2023, up €228 million since 2021;
— delivery of home support hours in communities is increasing, in line with enhanced investment;
— almost 20.8 million hours of home support was provided across the country in 2022, and this is 3 million more hours than were delivered in 2020;
— as of 31st August, 2023, over 14.3 million hours have been provided this year to date, and this is almost 600,000 hours more compared to the same period last year;
— addressing the shortage of care workers in Ireland is an urgent priority for the Government, with an implementation group established to implement the report of the Strategic Workforce Advisory Group on Home Carers and Nursing Home Health Care Assistants, in areas including pay and conditions of employment;
— a new tender for Home Support Services has been in place since August 2023, and this provides for a revised, increased rate to ensure that home support workers are paid appropriately, and to help address some of the key issues impacting the waiting lists and recruitment and retention;
— the Programme for Government: Our Shared Future commits to introduce a statutory scheme to support people to live in their own homes, which will provide equitable access to high quality, regulated home care;
— the heads of Bill are currently being drafted by the Department of Health, with a view to bringing the heads of Bill to Government for approval before the end of the year, and primary legislation has been prioritised for drafting in the Autumn Legislative Programme and the Department is engaging with key stakeholders;
— the draft regulations are at an advanced stage, informed by a public consultation, and legal advice and engagement with key stakeholders will assist with final revisions to regulations for providers of Home Support Services in 2023;
— the Health Information and Quality Authority is in the process of developing standards for home care and Home Support Services, which are in the early stages of development; and
— the new system of regulation for home support will ensure that the public can be confident that the services provided are of a high standard and will bring Ireland in line with best international practice.".
To delete all words after "Dáil Eireann" and substitute the following:
"recognises and notes:
— the invaluable work carried out by Home Care Support Assistants;
— that the Home Support Service is a core service for older people and is highly valued by service users;
— improving access to home support is a priority for the Government, with €723 million allocated in Budget 2023, up €228 million since 2021;
— delivery of home support hours in communities is increasing, in line with enhanced investment;
— almost 20.8 million hours of home support was provided across the country in 2022, and this is 3 million more hours than were delivered in 2020;
— as of 31st August, 2023, over 14.3 million hours have been provided this year to date, and this is almost 600,000 hours more compared to the same period last year;
— addressing the shortage of care workers in Ireland is an urgent priority for the Government, with an implementation group established to implement the report of the Strategic Workforce Advisory Group on Home Carers and Nursing Home Health Care Assistants, in areas including pay and conditions of employment;
— a new tender for Home Support Services has been in place since August 2023, and this provides for a revised, increased rate to ensure that home support workers are paid appropriately, and to help address some of the key issues impacting the waiting lists and recruitment and retention;
— the Programme for Government: Our Shared Future commits to introduce a statutory scheme to support people to live in their own homes, which will provide equitable access to high quality, regulated home care;
— the heads of Bill are currently being drafted by the Department of Health, with a view to bringing the heads of Bill to Government for approval before the end of the year, and primary legislation has been prioritised for drafting in the Autumn Legislative Programme and the Department is engaging with key stakeholders;
— the draft regulations are at an advanced stage, informed by a public consultation, and legal advice and engagement with key stakeholders will assist with final revisions to regulations for providers of Home Support Services in 2023;
— the Health Information and Quality Authority is in the process of developing standards for home care and Home Support Services, which are in the early stages of development; and
— the new system of regulation for home support will ensure that the public can be confident that the services provided are of a high standard and will bring Ireland in line with best international practice.".
Wording as published in the official Dáil record, unedited. Read the debate
The result
Carried- Tá (yes)
- 67
- Níl (no)
- 53
- Staon (abstain)
- 0
Tellers: Tá, Deputies Hildegarde Naughton and Cormac Devlin; Níl, Deputies Duncan Smith and Ged Nash.
Share this vote
Download the card or share the link to the full record.
The result applies to the question put. A vote alone does not tell you why a TD voted a particular way.
How each party voted
| Party | Tá | Níl | Staon | No vote | Most voted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fianna Fáil | 28 | – | – | – | Tá |
| Sinn Féin | – | 27 | – | – | Níl |
| Fine Gael | 26 | – | – | – | Tá |
| Green Party | 10 | – | – | 1 | Tá |
| Independent | – | 9 | – | – | No whip |
| Labour Party | – | 6 | – | – | Níl |
| Social Democrats | – | 4 | – | – | Níl |
| People Before Profit-Solidarity | – | 3 | – | – | Níl |
| Aontú | – | 1 | – | – | Níl |
| Independents 4 Change | – | 1 | – | – | Níl |
How every TD voted
Showing 116 of 116 TDs
- Aengus Ó SnodaighSinn Féin · Dublin South-CentralNíl
- Aindrias MoynihanFianna Fáil · Cork North-WestTá
- Alan DillonFine Gael · MayoTá
- Alan FarrellFine Gael · Dublin FingalTá
- Alan KellyLabour Party · Tipperary NorthNíl
- Aodhán Ó RíordáinLabour Party · Dublin Bay NorthNíl
- Barry CowenFianna Fáil · OffalyTá
- Bernard DurkanFine Gael · Kildare NorthTá
- Brendan GriffinFine Gael · KerryTá
- Brendan HowlinLabour Party · WexfordNíl
- Brendan SmithFianna Fáil · Cavan-MonaghanTá
- Brian LeddinGreen Party · Limerick CityTá
- Brian StanleyIndependent · LaoisNíl
- Carol NolanIndependent · OffalyNíl
- Cathal BerryIndependent · Kildare SouthNíl
- Cathal CroweFianna Fáil · ClareTá
- Catherine MartinGreen Party · Dublin RathdownTá
- Charles FlanaganFine Gael · LaoisTá
- Charlie McConalogueFianna Fáil · DonegalTá
- Christopher O'SullivanFianna Fáil · Cork South-WestTá
- Cian O'CallaghanSocial Democrats · Dublin Bay NorthNíl
- Ciarán CannonFine Gael · Galway EastTá
- Claire KerraneSinn Féin · Roscommon-GalwayNíl
- Colm BrophyFine Gael · Dublin South-WestTá
- Colm BurkeFine Gael · Cork North-CentralTá
- Cormac DevlinFianna Fáil · Dún LaoghaireTá
- Damien EnglishFine Gael · Meath WestTá
- Danny Healy-RaeIndependent · KerryNíl
- Darragh O'BrienFianna Fáil · Dublin Fingal EastTá
- Darren O'RourkeSinn Féin · Meath EastNíl
- David CullinaneSinn Féin · WaterfordNíl
- David StantonFine Gael · Cork EastTá
- Dessie EllisSinn Féin · Dublin North-WestNíl
- Donnchadh Ó LaoghaireSinn Féin · Cork South-CentralNíl
- Duncan SmithLabour Party · Dublin Fingal EastNíl
- Éamon Ó CuívFianna Fáil · Galway WestTá
- Eamon RyanGreen Party · Dublin Bay SouthTá
- Emer HigginsFine Gael · Dublin Mid-WestTá
- Eoin Ó BroinSinn Féin · Dublin Mid-WestNíl
- Fergus O'DowdFine Gael · LouthTá
- Francis Noel DuffyGreen Party · Dublin South-WestTá
- Frankie FeighanFine Gael · Sligo-LeitrimTá
- Gary GannonSocial Democrats · Dublin CentralNíl
- Ged NashLabour Party · LouthNíl
- Heather HumphreysFine Gael · Cavan-MonaghanTá
- Helen McEnteeFine Gael · Meath EastTá
- Hildegarde NaughtonFine Gael · Galway WestTá
- Imelda MunsterSinn Féin · LouthNíl
- Ivana BacikLabour Party · Dublin Bay SouthNíl
- Jack ChambersFianna Fáil · Dublin WestTá
- Jackie CahillFianna Fáil · TipperaryTá
- James BrowneFianna Fáil · WexfordTá
- Jennifer Murnane O'ConnorFianna Fáil · Carlow-KilkennyTá
- Jennifer WhitmoreSocial Democrats · WicklowNíl
- Jim O'CallaghanFianna Fáil · Dublin Bay SouthTá
- Joan CollinsIndependents 4 Change · Dublin South-CentralNíl
- Joe McHughFine Gael · DonegalTá
- Joe O'BrienGreen Party · Dublin FingalTá
- John BradySinn Féin · WicklowNíl
- John LahartFianna Fáil · Dublin South-WestTá
- John McGuinnessFianna Fáil · Carlow-KilkennyTá
- John Paul PhelanFine Gael · Carlow-KilkennyTá
- Johnny GuirkeSinn Féin · Meath WestNíl
- Johnny MythenSinn Féin · WexfordNíl
- Josepha MadiganFine Gael · Dublin RathdownTá
- Kathleen FunchionSinn Féin · Carlow-KilkennyNíl
- Kieran O'DonnellFine Gael · Limerick CityTá
- Louise O'ReillySinn Féin · Dublin Fingal WestNíl
- Marc Ó CathasaighGreen Party · WaterfordTá
- Martin BrowneSinn Féin · TipperaryNíl
- Martin KennySinn Féin · Sligo-LeitrimNíl
- Mary ButlerFianna Fáil · WaterfordTá
- Matt CarthySinn Féin · Cavan-MonaghanNíl
- Matt ShanahanIndependent · WaterfordNíl
- Mattie McGrathIndependent · Tipperary SouthNíl
- Maurice QuinlivanSinn Féin · Limerick CityNíl
- Michael CreedFine Gael · Cork North-WestTá
- Michael Healy-RaeIndependent · KerryNíl
- Michael McGrathFianna Fáil · Cork South-CentralTá
- Michael McNamaraIndependent · ClareNíl
- Michael MoynihanFianna Fáil · Cork North-WestTá
- Michael RingFine Gael · MayoTá
- Mick BarryPeople Before Profit-Solidarity · Cork North-CentralNíl
- Neale RichmondFine Gael · Dublin RathdownTá
- Neasa HouriganGreen Party · Dublin CentralNo vote
- Niall CollinsFianna Fáil · Limerick CountyTá
- Niamh SmythFianna Fáil · Cavan-MonaghanTá
- Norma FoleyFianna Fáil · KerryTá
- Ossian SmythGreen Party · Dún LaoghaireTá
- Pa DalySinn Féin · KerryNíl
- Pádraig Mac LochlainnSinn Féin · DonegalNíl
- Pádraig O'SullivanFianna Fáil · Cork North-CentralTá
- Pat BuckleySinn Féin · Cork EastNíl
- Patricia RyanSinn Féin · Kildare SouthNíl
- Patrick CostelloGreen Party · Dublin South-CentralTá
- Paul DonnellySinn Féin · Dublin WestNíl
- Paul KehoeFine Gael · WexfordTá
- Paul McAuliffeFianna Fáil · Dublin North-WestTá
- Paul MurphyPeople Before Profit-Solidarity · Dublin South-WestNíl
- Peadar TóibínAontú · Meath WestNíl
- Pearse DohertySinn Féin · DonegalNíl
- Richard Boyd BarrettPeople Before Profit-Solidarity · Dún LaoghaireNíl
- Richard BrutonFine Gael · Dublin Bay NorthTá
- Roderic O'GormanGreen Party · Dublin WestTá
- Róisín ShortallSocial Democrats · Dublin North-WestNíl
- Rose Conway-WalshSinn Féin · MayoNíl
- Ruairí Ó MurchúSinn Féin · LouthNíl
- Seán CroweSinn Féin · Dublin South-WestNíl
- Sean FlemingFianna Fáil · LaoisTá
- Seán HaugheyFianna Fáil · Dublin Bay NorthTá
- Simon HarrisFine Gael · WicklowTá
- Sorca ClarkeSinn Féin · Longford-WestmeathNíl
- Stephen DonnellyFianna Fáil · WicklowTá
- Steven MatthewsGreen Party · WicklowTá
- Violet-Anne WynneIndependent · ClareNíl
- Willie O'DeaFianna Fáil · Limerick CityTá
“No vote” lists sitting TDs with no recorded vote in this division. That includes the Ceann Comhairle, who votes only to break a tie, and TDs who were paired, away on ministerial or other business, or not yet elected at the time. A missing vote does not prove absence.
5 votes in the official tally could not be matched to a TD on DáilDex. The official record has the full list.
Party shown is the member's current party where their party history on the vote date is not yet recorded.
From Houses of the Oireachtas open data. Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Oireachtas (Open Data) PSI Licence.