Dáil vote · 23 September 2020
DáilDex record: 9727f09b
Workers’ Rights: Motion (Resumed) [Private Members]
Question put: "That the motion, as amended, be agreed to."
See how the TDs for your area voted, and get told next time.
How did your TDs vote?
Only the first three characters of your Eircode are used, and only in your browser.
What this vote means
Policy motion
A policy motion expresses the House's position or calls for action. It does not itself change the law or legally require the Government to carry out the policy requested.
Tá means yes and Níl means no to the exact question put. The vote alone does not establish a TD's full position or reasons.
DáilDex interpretation of the official wording.
The full text TDs voted on
This vote decided the motion as amended. Earlier in this debate amendment No. 1 replaced the original wording, so Tá supported the amendment's text below, not the original motion.
A motion can bundle several proposals together. Tá or Níl applies to the whole question put, so a TD may agree with one part and still vote against it because of another. Read the full wording, and the debate where TDs gave their reasons, before treating this vote as a position on any single point.
The motion as moved
That Dáil Éireann:
notes:
— the failure of the previous Government to legislate to implement the recommendations of the ‘Expert Examination and Review of Laws on the Protection of Employee Interests when assets are separated from the operating entity (Duffy-Cahill Report)’ which was commissioned following the closure of Clerys’ department store, and that this report made six recommendations aimed at protecting the rights of workers made redundant through insolvency;
— that a key recommendation of that report was that the State should have the right to chase up transferred assets and to use them to fund payments due to workers as per collective agreements; and
— workers at Debenhams Ireland are being denied their right to four weeks redundancy pay per year of service as per a collective agreement with their union, Mandate;
further notes the distinct possibility of a large number of closures and insolvencies due to the economic crisis caused by the Covid-19 pandemic, which could affect thousands of laid-off workers; and
calls on the Government to:
— introduce emergency legislation to implement the Duffy-Cahill Report recommendations as a matter of urgency; and
— examine the need for a ring-fenced insolvency fund, such as exists in several European Union states, to allow for all payments due to workers laid off by an insolvent company, which could be financed by a levy on employers Pay Related Social Insurance.
Amendment No. 1Decided in this vote
To delete all words after “Dáil Éireann” and substitute the following:
“acknowledges the difficulties faced by the workers affected by the loss of jobs resulting from Covid-19 and, in particular the liquidation of Debenhams Ireland;
notes that:
— the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste, as well as the relevant Ministers of State have met on a number of occasions, with Debenhams employees and their representatives, to hear directly from them their views and concerns;
— in respect of redundancy entitlements, it is the responsibility of the employer in the first instance to pay statutory redundancy and other wage related entitlements to eligible employees;
— the vast majority of employers act honourably and with full consideration for their workers when experiencing trading difficulties giving rise to redundancies;
— Debenhams Ireland is undergoing a High Court supervised liquidation and that there is no statutory role for Ministers of the Government to interfere with or influence that process;
— there is a clear distinction between the situation that pertained to Clerys and that which pertains to Debenhams – the former involving a significant property asset held in a separate company and not available to discharge obligations to creditors including employees, the latter not known to have any such asset;
— the only asset reported to be in consideration is some stock in the stores and that there may be many other legitimate claims on that asset, including from the suppliers of that stock, as well as public monies due to local authorities and the Revenue Commissioners;
— where, as a result of the insolvency of a company, the employer is unable to pay redundancy entitlements, whether basic statutory entitlements or enhanced redundancy collective agreements, the role of the State is to provide a safety net for former employees by paying statutory redundancy entitlements from the Social Insurance Fund;
— the Redundancy and Insolvency sections of the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection is engaged with the High Court appointed liquidator and will ensure that all claims in respect of employees of Debenhams are dealt with expeditiously; and
— as is proper to the role of Government, the ‘Job Loss Protocol’ has been activated for employees at Debenhams Ireland, putting in place all available supports and information for workers, including on welfare entitlements, job-search assistance and upskilling needs and opportunities;
recalls that the ‘Expert Examination and Review of Laws on the Protection of Employee Interests when assets are separated from the operating entity (Duffy-Cahill Report)’:
— which was commissioned by the Government in the aftermath of the Clerys closure,
made a number of future-orientated recommendations;
— highlighted how the issues raised by that event do not have simple solutions and would require further careful consideration involving consultation with many stakeholders;
— stated that ‘it is not desirable to create a special class of worker with legal rights that go beyond the generality of workers’, and noted the difficulties of determining whether an entitlement to enhanced redundancy would arise; and
— was sent to the Company Law Review Group (CLRG) in 2016 as part of the work of that group in advising the Minister for Business, Enterprise and Innovation on any changes that it considered necessary to company law;
further recalls that:
— in 2017, in parallel with the Duffy-Cahill Report, the CLRG undertook a root and branch review of the Companies Act 2014 to address concerns raised in respect of the protection of employees and unsecured creditors and the report, which emanated from this review by the CLRG, also generally found that the current provisions of the Companies Act 2014 provide a comprehensive framework which strikes a balance between the interests of members of a company and other stakeholders, including employees; and
— The CLRG did not include the implementation of the Duffy-Cahill Report in its recommendations;
considers that the issue of the retrospective application of future legislation is highly problematic and must be subject to legal advice from the Attorney General;
further notes that the Government is committed to, and is determined to, deliver on a number of actions in the Programme for Government, including to:
— review whether the legal provisions surrounding collective redundancies and the liquidation of companies effectively protect the rights of workers;
— review the Companies Acts with a view to addressing the practice of trading entities splitting their operations between trading and property with the result being the trading business (including jobs) go into insolvency and assets are taken out of the original business; and
— examine the legal provision that pertains to any sale to a connected party following insolvency of a company including who can object and allowable grounds of an objection;
agrees that the proposal from the Irish Congress of Trade Unions (ICTU) to examine the need for a ring-fenced insolvency fund is a valuable suggestion, worthy of further consideration and notes that the Government has further committed that it will progress this examination;
emphasises that broad consideration, not only across Government, but also among stakeholders such as employers, will be necessary in respect of such a fund; and
calls on all parties involved in the Debenhams dispute to enter into discussions and engage towards a fair resolution
Wording as published in the official Dáil record, unedited. Read the debate
The result
Carried- Tá (yes)
- 24
- Níl (no)
- 21
- Staon (abstain)
- 0
Tellers: Tá, Deputies Brendan Griffin and Jack Chambers; Níl, Deputies Joan Collins and Thomas Pringle.
Share this vote
Download the card or share the link to the full record.
The result applies to the question put. A vote alone does not tell you why a TD voted a particular way.
How each party voted
| Party | Tá | Níl | Staon | No vote | Most voted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sinn Féin | – | 10 | – | 2 | Níl |
| Fine Gael | 10 | – | – | – | Tá |
| Fianna Fáil | 9 | – | – | – | Tá |
| Green Party | 3 | – | – | 5 | Tá |
| Independent | 1 | 2 | – | 3 | No whip |
| Independents 4 Change | – | 2 | – | – | Níl |
| Labour Party | – | 2 | – | – | Níl |
| Social Democrats | – | 2 | – | – | Níl |
| Aontú | – | 1 | – | – | Níl |
| Independent Ireland | – | 1 | – | – | Níl |
| People Before Profit-Solidarity | – | 1 | – | – | Níl |
How every TD voted
Showing 54 of 54 TDs
- Aindrias MoynihanFianna Fáil · Cork North-WestTá
- Alan DillonFine Gael · MayoTá
- Alan FarrellFine Gael · Dublin FingalTá
- Aodhán Ó RíordáinLabour Party · Dublin Bay NorthNíl
- Bernard DurkanFine Gael · Kildare NorthTá
- Brendan GriffinFine Gael · KerryTá
- Brian LeddinGreen Party · Limerick CityTá
- Cathal BerryIndependent · Kildare SouthNo vote
- Cathal CroweFianna Fáil · ClareTá
- Catherine MurphySocial Democrats · Kildare NorthNíl
- Colm BurkeFine Gael · Cork North-CentralTá
- Damien EnglishFine Gael · Meath WestTá
- Danny Healy-RaeIndependent · KerryNíl
- Denis NaughtenIndependent · Roscommon-GalwayNíl
- Denise MitchellSinn Féin · Dublin Bay NorthNíl
- Éamon Ó CuívFianna Fáil · Galway WestTá
- Eoin Ó BroinSinn Féin · Dublin Mid-WestNíl
- Francis Noel DuffyGreen Party · Dublin South-WestNo vote
- Ged NashLabour Party · LouthNíl
- Helen McEnteeFine Gael · Meath EastTá
- Jack ChambersFianna Fáil · Dublin WestTá
- Jackie CahillFianna Fáil · TipperaryTá
- James O'ConnorFianna Fáil · Cork EastTá
- Joan CollinsIndependents 4 Change · Dublin South-CentralNíl
- Joe McHughFine Gael · DonegalTá
- Marc Ó CathasaighGreen Party · WaterfordTá
- Martin BrowneSinn Féin · TipperaryNíl
- Matt CarthySinn Féin · Cavan-MonaghanNíl
- Matt ShanahanIndependent · WaterfordNo vote
- Maurice QuinlivanSinn Féin · Limerick CityNíl
- Michael LowryIndependent · Tipperary NorthTá
- Michael McNamaraIndependent · ClareNo vote
- Mick BarryPeople Before Profit-Solidarity · Cork North-CentralNíl
- Neale RichmondFine Gael · Dublin RathdownTá
- Neasa HouriganGreen Party · Dublin CentralNo vote
- Niall CollinsFianna Fáil · Limerick CountyTá
- Ossian SmythGreen Party · Dún LaoghaireNo vote
- Pádraig Mac LochlainnSinn Féin · DonegalNíl
- Pádraig O'SullivanFianna Fáil · Cork North-CentralTá
- Patricia RyanSinn Féin · Kildare SouthNo vote
- Patrick CostelloGreen Party · Dublin South-CentralNo vote
- Paul DonnellySinn Féin · Dublin WestNíl
- Peadar TóibínAontú · Meath WestNíl
- Richard BrutonFine Gael · Dublin Bay NorthTá
- Richard O'DonoghueIndependent Ireland · Limerick CountyNíl
- Roderic O'GormanGreen Party · Dublin WestTá
- Róisín ShortallSocial Democrats · Dublin North-WestNíl
- Ruairí Ó MurchúSinn Féin · LouthNíl
- Seán CroweSinn Féin · Dublin South-WestNíl
- Sean FlemingFianna Fáil · LaoisTá
- Sorca ClarkeSinn Féin · Longford-WestmeathNíl
- Steven MatthewsGreen Party · WicklowNo vote
- Thomas PringleIndependents 4 Change · DonegalNíl
- Violet-Anne WynneSinn Féin · ClareNo vote
“No vote” lists sitting TDs with no recorded vote in this division. That includes the Ceann Comhairle, who votes only to break a tie, and TDs who were paired, away on ministerial or other business, or not yet elected at the time. A missing vote does not prove absence.
1 vote in the official tally could not be matched to a TD on DáilDex. The official record has the full list.
Party shown is the member's current party where their party history on the vote date is not yet recorded.
From Houses of the Oireachtas open data. Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Oireachtas (Open Data) PSI Licence.