Dáil vote · 21 February 2024
DáilDex record: ad35fe7d
Paediatric Orthopaedic and Urology Services: Motion (Resumed) [Private Members]
Amendment put
See how the TDs for your area voted, and get told next time.
How did your TDs vote?
Only the first three characters of your Eircode are used, and only in your browser.
What this vote means
Policy motion · Amendment
This is a vote on an amendment. Tá and Níl refer to that amendment, rather than the whole Bill or motion. Check whether it proposes adding, removing or replacing words.
A policy motion expresses the House's position or calls for action. It does not itself change the law or legally require the Government to carry out the policy requested.
The exact wording is not supplied in this division record. Check the official debate.
Tá means yes and Níl means no to the exact question put. The vote alone does not establish a TD's full position or reasons.
DáilDex interpretation of the official wording.
The full text TDs voted on
This vote decided amendment No. 1. It deletes the motion's wording and puts its own text in its place. Tá supported replacing the original text; Níl opposed replacing it. Neither is a vote on the original motion by itself.
A motion can bundle several proposals together. Tá or Níl applies to the whole question put, so a TD may agree with one part and still vote against it because of another. Read the full wording, and the debate where TDs gave their reasons, before treating this vote as a position on any single point.
The motion as moved
That Dáil Éireann:
notes that, as of 13th February, 2024, there are 327 children listed as waiting on a scoliosis-related surgery with Children's Health Ireland (CHI), as compared to 312 in February 2017;
recalls the commitment given by the then Minister for Health, Simon Harris TD, in March 2017 that no child would wait more than four months for spinal surgery by the end of that year;
further notes that:
— 78 per cent of children are waiting longer than the Sláintecare target time for a paediatric orthopaedic inpatient appointment with CHI, and 81 per cent are waiting longer than the target time for paediatric urology;
— 84 per cent of children are waiting longer than the Sláintecare target time for a paediatric orthopaedic outpatient appointment with CHI, and 72 per cent are waiting longer than the target time for paediatric urology; and
— there is still uncertainty regarding the timeline for the transfer of services to the new Children's Hospital from the various Children's Health Ireland sites, and there are major concerns that a vast majority of children currently waiting for care will age out of paediatrics untreated;
expresses concern that:
— additional resources were made available to CHI to improve paediatric orthopaedic services, but members of the Oireachtas, members of the Government, patient advocates, and clinicians have expressed significant concerns regarding the use, extent, and effectiveness of this funding; and
— spinal surgical activity at CHI has been impacted by the voluntary leave of a consultant following significant concerns regarding return to surgery rates, infection rates, and allegations of inappropriate implantations at CHI Temple Street, the matters of which are subject to numerous reviews;
acknowledges:
— that the position of patient advocates is that existing reviews into CHI paediatric orthopaedic services are insufficient, too narrow in scope, and unlikely to have a satisfactory impact or reveal the true extent of the problem;
— the letter sent by the Minister for Health to patient advocates dated 6th February, 2024, which states that a paediatric spinal surgery unit will be established within Children's Health Ireland, that a lead has been appointed, and that the Minister "would like to convene a Taskforce"; and
— that the position of patient advocates is that a comprehensive, transparent, structured programme of work should be carried out by an independent taskforce, to include a comprehensive examination of the range of services related to scoliosis and spina bifida, care pathways, health care infrastructure, and the related governance of CHI;
considers that the Government has failed to deliver on its health and social care commitments to children, and that children's health care services are not operating at a satisfactory level as evidenced in the Sláintecare waiting list metrics;
demands that these systemic and historical failures are not allowed to continue as children deserve better; and
calls on the Government to:
— establish a taskforce which is independent of CHI management, which will be mandated to listen, engage, and act on the advice and concerns of parents, patient advocates, and clinicians, and include these stakeholders in its reporting process;
— mandate the independent taskforce to conduct a comprehensive review of scoliosis and spina bifida services, including transitional care, post-surgical specialist rehabilitation, and full and appropriate access to community services;
— deliver equitable and quality access to care that is evidence-based and in line with international best practice;
— ensure access to children's health services and treatments is provided on the basis of clinical need and not ability to pay;
— establish a sustainable public model of delivering specialist care for children with scoliosis and/or spina bifida, with increased public provision of care and a reduced reliance on private providers;
— make best use of international service options where clinically appropriate, and provide a wraparound care package for children and their parents/guardians, to include follow-up care post-operatively in Ireland as this is the main barrier for travelling abroad for children who can travel;
— resource and expand the paediatric orthopaedic elective care centre at the National Orthopaedic Hospital Cappagh, including provision of paediatric critical care capacity to support complex surgeries and children deemed clinically complex;
— assess a suitable location for the provision of an elective paediatric urology service and deliver such a service; and
— establish a permanent engagement process with patient advocacy and parent groups with lived experience, such as Spina Bifida Hydrocephalus Paediatric Advocacy Group and the Scoliosis Advocacy Network and others, at senior management level following the work of the taskforce.
Amendment No. 1Decided in this vote
To delete all words after "Dáil Éireann" and substitute the following:
"recognises that:
— waiting lists for spinal surgery remain too long, despite an increase in the number of procedures carried out in recent years; and
— the Government is committed to improving the waiting time for children seeking care;
notes that:
— the Government allocated €19 million of current and capital funding to help tackle these waiting lists by creating additional capacity;
— the €19 million investment supported an increase in the number of spinal procedures undertaken by our healthcare workers in both 2022 and 2023;
— 509 spinal procedures were carried out in 2022, and in 2023 464 spinal procedures were carried out as compared to 380 in 2019; this represents a 34 per cent increase and a 22 per cent increase respectively compared to 2019;
— at the end of December 2023 there were 78 active patients waiting over four months, which is a 13 per cent reduction compared to the end of 2022; and there were 231 patients waiting for spinal procedures, excluding suspensions, which is a five per cent reduction compared to the end of 2022;
— this Government will continue to invest significant funding to help reduce the amount of time children are waiting for important hospital appointments and procedures;
— Scoliosis and Spina Bifida were identified as a priority area, one of three priority areas, in both the 2022 and 2023 Waiting List Action Plans; and
— Scoliosis and Spina Bifida services will remain as priority areas under the 2024 Waiting List Action Plan;
further notes that:
— the Minister for Health intends to convene a Taskforce and invited all patient groups to input into the Terms of Reference;
— a dedicated Paediatric Spinal Surgery Management Unit has been established in Children's Health Ireland, which is focusing on the management and delivery of spinal surgery, including increased activity and further reducing the waiting lists;
— a Clinical Speciality Lead for Spinal Surgery, a Nurse Manager, and Business Manager have all commenced in post;
— work is underway on a paediatric spinal care programme of work which involves actions to tackle the current waiting lists, the design and transition to a dedicated Paediatric Spinal Service, and outsourcing options for clinically suitable children; and
— this Government is committed to seeing the new Children's Hospital opened as soon as possible.".
Wording as published in the official Dáil record, unedited. Read the debate
The result
Carried- Tá (yes)
- 71
- Níl (no)
- 60
- Staon (abstain)
- 0
Tellers: Tá, Deputies Hildegarde Naughton and Cormac Devlin; Níl, Deputies Pádraig Mac Lochlainn and Denise Mitchell.
Share this vote
Download the card or share the link to the full record.
The result applies to the question put. A vote alone does not tell you why a TD voted a particular way.
How each party voted
| Party | Tá | Níl | Staon | No vote | Most voted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fianna Fáil | 32 | – | – | – | Tá |
| Sinn Féin | – | 30 | – | – | Níl |
| Fine Gael | 27 | – | – | – | Tá |
| Green Party | 9 | – | – | 2 | Tá |
| Independent | – | 11 | – | – | No whip |
| Labour Party | – | 7 | – | – | Níl |
| Social Democrats | – | 6 | – | – | Níl |
| Independents 4 Change | – | 2 | – | – | Níl |
| Aontú | – | 1 | – | – | Níl |
| People Before Profit-Solidarity | – | 1 | – | – | Níl |
How every TD voted
Showing 128 of 128 TDs
- Aengus Ó SnodaighSinn Féin · Dublin South-CentralNíl
- Aindrias MoynihanFianna Fáil · Cork North-WestTá
- Alan DillonFine Gael · MayoTá
- Alan FarrellFine Gael · Dublin FingalTá
- Alan KellyLabour Party · Tipperary NorthNíl
- Aodhán Ó RíordáinLabour Party · Dublin Bay NorthNíl
- Barry CowenFianna Fáil · OffalyTá
- Bernard DurkanFine Gael · Kildare NorthTá
- Brendan GriffinFine Gael · KerryTá
- Brendan HowlinLabour Party · WexfordNíl
- Brendan SmithFianna Fáil · Cavan-MonaghanTá
- Brian LeddinGreen Party · Limerick CityTá
- Brian StanleyIndependent · LaoisNíl
- Cathal BerryIndependent · Kildare SouthNíl
- Catherine ConnollyIndependents 4 Change · Galway WestNíl
- Catherine MartinGreen Party · Dublin RathdownTá
- Catherine MurphySocial Democrats · Kildare NorthNíl
- Charlie McConalogueFianna Fáil · DonegalTá
- Christopher O'SullivanFianna Fáil · Cork South-WestTá
- Cian O'CallaghanSocial Democrats · Dublin Bay NorthNíl
- Ciarán CannonFine Gael · Galway EastTá
- Claire KerraneSinn Féin · Roscommon-GalwayNíl
- Colm BrophyFine Gael · Dublin South-WestTá
- Colm BurkeFine Gael · Cork North-CentralTá
- Cormac DevlinFianna Fáil · Dún LaoghaireTá
- Damien EnglishFine Gael · Meath WestTá
- Danny Healy-RaeIndependent · KerryNíl
- Dara CallearyFianna Fáil · MayoTá
- Darragh O'BrienFianna Fáil · Dublin Fingal EastTá
- Darren O'RourkeSinn Féin · Meath EastNíl
- David CullinaneSinn Féin · WaterfordNíl
- Denise MitchellSinn Féin · Dublin Bay NorthNíl
- Dessie EllisSinn Féin · Dublin North-WestNíl
- Duncan SmithLabour Party · Dublin Fingal EastNíl
- Éamon Ó CuívFianna Fáil · Galway WestTá
- Eamon RyanGreen Party · Dublin Bay SouthTá
- Emer HigginsFine Gael · Dublin Mid-WestTá
- Eoin Ó BroinSinn Féin · Dublin Mid-WestNíl
- Fergus O'DowdFine Gael · LouthTá
- Francis Noel DuffyGreen Party · Dublin South-WestTá
- Frankie FeighanFine Gael · Sligo-LeitrimTá
- Gary GannonSocial Democrats · Dublin CentralNíl
- Ged NashLabour Party · LouthNíl
- Heather HumphreysFine Gael · Cavan-MonaghanTá
- Helen McEnteeFine Gael · Meath EastTá
- Hildegarde NaughtonFine Gael · Galway WestTá
- Holly CairnsSocial Democrats · Cork South-WestNíl
- Imelda MunsterSinn Féin · LouthNíl
- Ivana BacikLabour Party · Dublin Bay SouthNíl
- Jack ChambersFianna Fáil · Dublin WestTá
- Jackie CahillFianna Fáil · TipperaryTá
- James BrowneFianna Fáil · WexfordTá
- James LawlessFianna Fáil · Kildare NorthTá
- James O'ConnorFianna Fáil · Cork EastTá
- Jennifer Carroll MacNeillFine Gael · Dún LaoghaireTá
- Jennifer Murnane O'ConnorFianna Fáil · Carlow-KilkennyTá
- Jennifer WhitmoreSocial Democrats · WicklowNíl
- Jim O'CallaghanFianna Fáil · Dublin Bay SouthTá
- Joan CollinsIndependents 4 Change · Dublin South-CentralNíl
- Joe McHughFine Gael · DonegalTá
- Joe O'BrienGreen Party · Dublin FingalTá
- John BradySinn Féin · WicklowNíl
- John LahartFianna Fáil · Dublin South-WestTá
- John McGuinnessFianna Fáil · Carlow-KilkennyTá
- Johnny GuirkeSinn Féin · Meath WestNíl
- Johnny MythenSinn Féin · WexfordNíl
- Josepha MadiganFine Gael · Dublin RathdownTá
- Kieran O'DonnellFine Gael · Limerick CityTá
- Louise O'ReillySinn Féin · Dublin Fingal WestNíl
- Mairéad FarrellSinn Féin · Galway WestNíl
- Marc Ó CathasaighGreen Party · WaterfordTá
- Marian HarkinIndependent · Sligo-LeitrimNíl
- Mark WardSinn Féin · Dublin Mid-WestNíl
- Martin BrowneSinn Féin · TipperaryNíl
- Martin HeydonFine Gael · Kildare SouthTá
- Martin KennySinn Féin · Sligo-LeitrimNíl
- Mary ButlerFianna Fáil · WaterfordTá
- Mary Lou McDonaldSinn Féin · Dublin CentralNíl
- Matt ShanahanIndependent · WaterfordNíl
- Mattie McGrathIndependent · Tipperary SouthNíl
- Maurice QuinlivanSinn Féin · Limerick CityNíl
- Michael LowryIndependent · Tipperary NorthNíl
- Michael McGrathFianna Fáil · Cork South-CentralTá
- Michael McNamaraIndependent · ClareNíl
- Michael MoynihanFianna Fáil · Cork North-WestTá
- Michael RingFine Gael · MayoTá
- Micheál MartinFianna Fáil · Cork South-CentralTá
- Mick BarryPeople Before Profit-Solidarity · Cork North-CentralNíl
- Neale RichmondFine Gael · Dublin RathdownTá
- Neasa HouriganGreen Party · Dublin CentralNo vote
- Niamh SmythFianna Fáil · Cavan-MonaghanTá
- Norma FoleyFianna Fáil · KerryTá
- Ossian SmythGreen Party · Dún LaoghaireTá
- Pa DalySinn Féin · KerryNíl
- Pádraig Mac LochlainnSinn Féin · DonegalNíl
- Pádraig O'SullivanFianna Fáil · Cork North-CentralTá
- Paschal DonohoeFine Gael · Dublin CentralTá
- Pat BuckleySinn Féin · Cork EastNíl
- Patricia RyanSinn Féin · Kildare SouthNíl
- Patrick CostelloGreen Party · Dublin South-CentralNo vote
- Patrick O'DonovanFine Gael · Limerick CountyTá
- Paul DonnellySinn Féin · Dublin WestNíl
- Paul McAuliffeFianna Fáil · Dublin North-WestTá
- Peadar TóibínAontú · Meath WestNíl
- Pearse DohertySinn Féin · DonegalNíl
- Peter BurkeFine Gael · Longford-WestmeathTá
- Réada CroninSinn Féin · Kildare NorthNíl
- Richard BrutonFine Gael · Dublin Bay NorthTá
- Robert TroyFianna Fáil · Longford-WestmeathTá
- Roderic O'GormanGreen Party · Dublin WestTá
- Róisín ShortallSocial Democrats · Dublin North-WestNíl
- Rose Conway-WalshSinn Féin · MayoNíl
- Ruairí Ó MurchúSinn Féin · LouthNíl
- Seán CanneyIndependent · Galway EastNíl
- Seán CroweSinn Féin · Dublin South-WestNíl
- Sean FlemingFianna Fáil · LaoisTá
- Seán HaugheyFianna Fáil · Dublin Bay NorthTá
- Seán SherlockLabour Party · Cork EastNíl
- Simon CoveneyFine Gael · Cork South-CentralTá
- Simon HarrisFine Gael · WicklowTá
- Sorca ClarkeSinn Féin · Longford-WestmeathNíl
- Stephen DonnellyFianna Fáil · WicklowTá
- Steven MatthewsGreen Party · WicklowTá
- Thomas ByrneFianna Fáil · Meath EastTá
- Thomas GouldSinn Féin · Cork North-CentralNíl
- Verona MurphyIndependent · WexfordNíl
- Violet-Anne WynneIndependent · ClareNíl
- Willie O'DeaFianna Fáil · Limerick CityTá
“No vote” lists sitting TDs with no recorded vote in this division. That includes the Ceann Comhairle, who votes only to break a tie, and TDs who were paired, away on ministerial or other business, or not yet elected at the time. A missing vote does not prove absence.
5 votes in the official tally could not be matched to a TD on DáilDex. The official record has the full list.
Party shown is the member's current party where their party history on the vote date is not yet recorded.
From Houses of the Oireachtas open data. Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Oireachtas (Open Data) PSI Licence.